Gear Box VS Belt Drive

Well what I got from Flippers post is there is a gear-reduction-pump, GR spec, certainly not popular as I don't think anyone's ever seen one. Somewhere under the Karcher umbrella at least and for some reason it is spec-ed to run faster than a belt.
 
Jerry it couldn't have been said better if it was a direct copy and paste from the spec sheet. bore and stroke times rpm equals rated flow, flow through a given orifice gives pressure.
It's crazy how much difference a millimeter makes in the flow.
 
Flipper.. What are you thinking !??
IF you have an engine driven pump in your product line that runs at 700rpm belt driven..
that's a 5:1 ratio from a 3600rpm motor.. which means.. with a 3.2" pulley on the motor, the pump will have a 16" diameter..
Really ?? can you post a picture of that ?
Gasoline engine rpm is set around 3200rpm. A direct drive pump is designed to turn at 3400 rpm for gas engines. A belt driven pump is designed to turn at various rpm in a range of 650 to 3400rpm depending on design requirements.

..And your 2300rpm direct drive.. what engine are you running at 2300rpm ?? can you post that ??
Our engines ran on average 3200 rpm most direct drivepumps operate at 3400 rpm. A gear reducing typically has a 2.1 to 1reduction ratio. An engine set at 3600 rpm will turn the pump at 1750 rpm. If you have a standard pump that is designed to operate at 1750 rpm and has thesame shaft size as the gear reduction then you can connect this pump to a gearreduction. Gear reductions will come with pump shaft sizes in either 24mm or30mm and the other side for the engine will be either 1” or 1 1/8”. Oh, and I don't know why the text came out red.
 
Good thread. Rance asked the right question, and Jerry and Greg nailed the main point.

The pump doesn't care how it's driven. It needs its rated RPM to make its rated GPM. Belts or a gearbox just get it there from engine speed.

Here's how I'd sum up the two:

  • Gearbox: compact, fewer exposed moving parts, nothing to adjust. Check the gear oil and use the oil the gearbox maker calls for.
  • Belt drive: belts soak up some shock and vibration, and you can change the pulley ratio. You do have to keep belts tight and guards on.
  • Bigger pumps: some guys in here had keyway and mounting trouble with gearboxes on higher GPM setups. If you go that way, buy a gearbox rated for that pump and engine.
  • Either way, match the pump RPM to the engine. Don't overspin a pump to chase more pressure.

Both work. Pick what you can service and what fits your rig. Then keep up the maintenance.

Ron Musgraves
 
Back
Top