Russ Spence
Commercial Pressure Wash Expert
Senator John McCain said Wednesday if Major League Baseball doesn't adopt a more stringent drug testing policy, Congress may be forced to step in. McCain, chairman of the Senate Commerce Committee, spoke at a hearing on Wednesday and said because of baseball's relaxed drug-testing plan there is "a legitimacy problem" in the sport.
"As your athletes get bigger and stronger, the credibility of your product in the eyes of the public gets weaker," McCain (R-AZ) said. "I am hopeful that this hearing will be the first step toward clearing the cloud of suspicion that looms ominously over your sports."
Major League Baseball commissioner Bud Selig and union head Donald Fehr testified during the hearing before the Senate Commerce Committee. NFL commissioner Paul Tagliabue and union boss Gene Upshaw also testified, as did Terry Madden, Chief Executive Officer of the United States Anti-Doping Agency.
The NFL received praise from senators for its drug-testing policy. A typical penalty for a first violation of the league's anabolic steroids policy is a four-week suspension, costing the player 25 percent of his annual salary. In 1990, the NFL became the first league to test players for steroid use.
However, many senators, and even Madden, were quick to criticize Major League Baseball for its testing policy, ironed out in the 2002 collective bargaining agreement. Starting this season, a first positive test for steroid use would result in treatment. A second offense carries a 15-day suspension or fine of up to $10,000. A third offense is a 25-day suspension or up to a $25,000 fine and a fourth a 50-day suspension or a fine up to $50,000. A fifth positive test is either a one-year suspension or a fine of up to $100,000. All suspensions are without pay.
Major League Baseball, specifically Fehr, was criticized by senators, who said they were upset about baseball's policy. Under the guidelines, baseball players are subjected only to in-season testing and only one time. A positive test however could trigger more testing of that player.
"Major League Baseball doesn't test in the offseason. How can that possibly be? That's when the training goes on," said Senator Jay Rockefeller (D-WV). "Baseball players are tested only twice each year. That's easy to work around.
"I blame the union. The union over the years has been very destructive on this. They're not helpful. I blame management. I blame the administration of the league for not cracking down at what is such an obvious problem, which is an embarrassment to the United States, which is hurtful to fans all over the country."
Madden had some suggestions for baseball.
"They need to do year-round out of competition no-notice testing," Madden said. "They'd have to have significantly more serious sanctions. They'd have to be transparent announcing a ball player when he does become positive and they go through their adjudication procedures. They need to test from a complete list of prohibited substances."
McCain asked Selig and Fehr if both would be willing to adopt a comprehensive drug-testing policy like the one in the NFL. Selig was receptive to the idea, but Fehr skirted around the question when asked for a direct "yes" or "no" answer from McCain. Fehr did, however, say that provisions in the collective bargaining agreement call for periodic review.
"Under those, we're certainly willing to sit down and discuss any new ideas and to look at matters in light of new information," Fehr said. "I believe that the program we have instituted has had some affect."
McCain seemed to be hoping for a stronger commitment from Fehr.
"Your failure to commit to address this issue, straight on and immediately, will motivate this committee to search for legislative remedies," McCain said. "I can tell you and your players you represent, the status quo is not acceptable. We will have to act in some way unless the major league players association acts in a affirmative and rapid fashion. The integrity of the sport and the American people demand a certain level of adherence and standards, that are frankly not being met at this time."
Selig admitted there was a problem and the agreement that was signed between the owners and union in 2002 was a compromise, mostly to avert a work stoppage.
"We accepted less than we wanted because, in my judgment as the Commissioner, we had pushed the MLBPA as far as it would go without a strike and, equally important, the clubs, whatever their convictions, were profoundly concerned about the impact of another strike," Selig said in his testimony.
Selig noted he hopes to adopt the policy now present at the minor league level and apply it to players who are under major league contracts. Under the minor league policy, there is a year-round testing program and first-time offenders are hit with a 15-game suspension.
"This a problem that needs to be addressed for a myriad of reasons," Selig said. "There are health reasons. There are competitive issues. I'm very hopeful we can address the problem very expeditiously."
The steroids issue has developed into a huge topic this spring with fingers being pointed at a bunch of major league players.
According to a published report last week, slugger and New York players and were some of the professional athletes who received steroids that came from the Bay Area Laboratory Co-Operative (BALCO). Four men were charged last month with distributing illegal drugs, including steroids and human growth hormones.
The hearings were the latest developments in a series of movements against steroids. Last week, House Judiciary Chairman F. James Sensenbrenner, Jr. (R- Wisc.) speared an effort to curb the use of steroids in sports as the Anabolic Steroid Control Act of 2004 was introduced. The new legislation would update the list of illegal dangerous substances being marketed as performance enhancers. It would also increase the penalties for those who traffic the substances within 1,000 feet of a sports facility.
On a side note, according to a report published in Wednesday's New York Daily News, Fehr has been offered a three-year contract from the players worth about $2.5 million per year. Fehr has not had a multi-year pact since 1992.
"As your athletes get bigger and stronger, the credibility of your product in the eyes of the public gets weaker," McCain (R-AZ) said. "I am hopeful that this hearing will be the first step toward clearing the cloud of suspicion that looms ominously over your sports."
Major League Baseball commissioner Bud Selig and union head Donald Fehr testified during the hearing before the Senate Commerce Committee. NFL commissioner Paul Tagliabue and union boss Gene Upshaw also testified, as did Terry Madden, Chief Executive Officer of the United States Anti-Doping Agency.
The NFL received praise from senators for its drug-testing policy. A typical penalty for a first violation of the league's anabolic steroids policy is a four-week suspension, costing the player 25 percent of his annual salary. In 1990, the NFL became the first league to test players for steroid use.
However, many senators, and even Madden, were quick to criticize Major League Baseball for its testing policy, ironed out in the 2002 collective bargaining agreement. Starting this season, a first positive test for steroid use would result in treatment. A second offense carries a 15-day suspension or fine of up to $10,000. A third offense is a 25-day suspension or up to a $25,000 fine and a fourth a 50-day suspension or a fine up to $50,000. A fifth positive test is either a one-year suspension or a fine of up to $100,000. All suspensions are without pay.
Major League Baseball, specifically Fehr, was criticized by senators, who said they were upset about baseball's policy. Under the guidelines, baseball players are subjected only to in-season testing and only one time. A positive test however could trigger more testing of that player.
"Major League Baseball doesn't test in the offseason. How can that possibly be? That's when the training goes on," said Senator Jay Rockefeller (D-WV). "Baseball players are tested only twice each year. That's easy to work around.
"I blame the union. The union over the years has been very destructive on this. They're not helpful. I blame management. I blame the administration of the league for not cracking down at what is such an obvious problem, which is an embarrassment to the United States, which is hurtful to fans all over the country."
Madden had some suggestions for baseball.
"They need to do year-round out of competition no-notice testing," Madden said. "They'd have to have significantly more serious sanctions. They'd have to be transparent announcing a ball player when he does become positive and they go through their adjudication procedures. They need to test from a complete list of prohibited substances."
McCain asked Selig and Fehr if both would be willing to adopt a comprehensive drug-testing policy like the one in the NFL. Selig was receptive to the idea, but Fehr skirted around the question when asked for a direct "yes" or "no" answer from McCain. Fehr did, however, say that provisions in the collective bargaining agreement call for periodic review.
"Under those, we're certainly willing to sit down and discuss any new ideas and to look at matters in light of new information," Fehr said. "I believe that the program we have instituted has had some affect."
McCain seemed to be hoping for a stronger commitment from Fehr.
"Your failure to commit to address this issue, straight on and immediately, will motivate this committee to search for legislative remedies," McCain said. "I can tell you and your players you represent, the status quo is not acceptable. We will have to act in some way unless the major league players association acts in a affirmative and rapid fashion. The integrity of the sport and the American people demand a certain level of adherence and standards, that are frankly not being met at this time."
Selig admitted there was a problem and the agreement that was signed between the owners and union in 2002 was a compromise, mostly to avert a work stoppage.
"We accepted less than we wanted because, in my judgment as the Commissioner, we had pushed the MLBPA as far as it would go without a strike and, equally important, the clubs, whatever their convictions, were profoundly concerned about the impact of another strike," Selig said in his testimony.
Selig noted he hopes to adopt the policy now present at the minor league level and apply it to players who are under major league contracts. Under the minor league policy, there is a year-round testing program and first-time offenders are hit with a 15-game suspension.
"This a problem that needs to be addressed for a myriad of reasons," Selig said. "There are health reasons. There are competitive issues. I'm very hopeful we can address the problem very expeditiously."
The steroids issue has developed into a huge topic this spring with fingers being pointed at a bunch of major league players.
According to a published report last week, slugger and New York players and were some of the professional athletes who received steroids that came from the Bay Area Laboratory Co-Operative (BALCO). Four men were charged last month with distributing illegal drugs, including steroids and human growth hormones.
The hearings were the latest developments in a series of movements against steroids. Last week, House Judiciary Chairman F. James Sensenbrenner, Jr. (R- Wisc.) speared an effort to curb the use of steroids in sports as the Anabolic Steroid Control Act of 2004 was introduced. The new legislation would update the list of illegal dangerous substances being marketed as performance enhancers. It would also increase the penalties for those who traffic the substances within 1,000 feet of a sports facility.
On a side note, according to a report published in Wednesday's New York Daily News, Fehr has been offered a three-year contract from the players worth about $2.5 million per year. Fehr has not had a multi-year pact since 1992.